Sunday, June 14, 2009

Dear Upwardly Mobile College Students STOP GOING TO LAW SCHOOL

This is a plague that anyone who knows me knows I complain about: College kids, especially those who come from parents who have money, are going to Law school because they have no idea what they want to do with their lives - just that they want to make enough money to be relatively rich and not have work too hard to get it.

Where once people who were about their direction in life, came from money, and got an education, went to medical school, they are now choosing the "easier" or at least perceived easier future of being a lawyer.

Most of the people who are going to law school today are relatively unintelligent intellectually lazy college graduates who just don't know what else they want to do.

Yes, law school is hard, but the standards are lower then what it takes to get into medical school and the result used to be and is still perceived that it leads to a definite job that pays well.

As such there is an increasing glut of law school graduates, which has led to many law school graduates not being hired. This (as someone with an economics degree can tell you) is great news, maybe people will stop going to law school.

As a son, grandson and more, of lawyers I was so turned off by the way students get into, study, and become lawyers I knew it could not be my future. We need intelligent cutting edge thinkers whose love is the law; the execution and arguing over it.

Spoiled kids who don't know what else to do only cheapen the profession and dilute legal thinking.

Law Schools need to stop trading short term money at the cost of the profession they are poorly training people for.

For now this article is a start:
And yet, here we are. Wandering from LSAT prep to McKinsey Q&As to Teach For America informationals, we’re looking for something: a paying job, any job. A benefactor. The problem is, our personal passions do not give rise to prepared professions. Our myriad talents do not seem to converge upon one—or more importantly, one lucrative—career. As such, we’ve lapsed into months-long lamentations about our accursed lacked of direction. Simply, we have no idea where we’re going.

It hasn’t always been this way. Long before we were “without direction,” we used to be called “well-rounded.” The scatterplot of interests that’s plaguing us now once got us into college. Back in those days, we were overachievers, full of belief in the beauty of our dreams. Never mind the obvious: that we never had a plan for making those dreams come true. “Rule the world” (or save it) was a perfect answer for all who asked:

What do you want to do after you graduate?

The I-bank/Law School/Med School Model of Success posits three options:

1) To try to make lots of money now.
2) To go to professional school now and try to make lots of money later.
3) To try to make lots of money now then go to school and try to make even more money sooner.

In desperation almost, we’ve begun to subscribe to this Triumvirate Vision of Success. We artists and actors have begun to think that maybe marketing’s not so bad. Consulting has become a seductive lesser of evils, second only to the catholicon that is Law School. It’s the validation sticker we’ve worn for years to explain (or excuse) our interests. When people ask, “What are you studying?” our answer has always been two-fold. First, the program (“History,” “Theater”) and then the plan: “But I’m going to law school.” How quickly the confusion (“Gender Studies?!”) gives way to “Aha!”’s of comprehension.

Of course, now that the day is upon us, we must appraise the master plan. The most fickle among us (myself included) seek solace in the Apply-and-Defer-Approach. Gifted scholars, dancers, teachers, poets—we know we don’t want to be lawyers. But in the name of appeasing parents, perceptions, and Pell Grants, we log onto LSAC.

Here’s the thing. If you:

a) Are going to law school because you’re not going to medical school,
b) Are going to law school because you’re smart and don’t know what else to do,
c) Imagine law school as an extension of your liberal arts education,

please reconsider. Going to law school with no interest in legal practice is much like fulfilling all the pre-med requirements without any inclination to become a doctor. Unless you truly adore math and science you’d have worked too hard for too little.
To sum DON'T GO TO LAW SCHOOL do something else for goodness sakes.

http://blackjew.blogspot.com/atom.xmlRSS Digg!

Labels: , , , ,

Comments on "Dear Upwardly Mobile College Students STOP GOING TO LAW SCHOOL"

 

Anonymous Law School Grad said ... (3:34 AM) : 

"Most of the people who are going to law school today are relatively unintelligent intellectually lazy college graduates who just don't know what else they want to do."

Wow, really? What an ignorant and stupid thing to say, but most importantly completely incorrect. Did you not get in to law school or something? Also it's a little bit ridiculous for you to say that most people who go to law school have rich parents. While that might be true of many law students it's DEF not true of all of us. Your statement shows you lack any real exposure to law students en mass.

Also this is so disgustingly biased it makes me laugh "Yes, law school is hard, but the standards are lower then what it takes to get into medical school and the result used to be and is still perceived that it leads to a definite job that pays well." While it's true that Medical school is probably the most difficult doctoral program to gain entry to, I think you're kidding yourself to say that law school is that far behind it. I know many students with high GPAs, MAs and work experience who can't get in to ANY law schools and (as many med students) must go through 2 rounds of apps to get in anywhere.

This "blog entry" should embarrass you because it shows you actually know nothing about law school (in its current state), law students, or the legal profession.

Discouraging upwardly mobile college students from going to law school isn't as noble a goal as you dream it to be.

Also, what does this have to do with the Black/Jewish experience??? As a natural born African-American Jew and lawyer I'd really like to see you argue that this is relevant in any way.

Good Day.

 

Anonymous Law Schooler who is unintelligent and intellectually lazy said ... (3:46 AM) : 

This is also totally false "As such there is an increasing glut of law school graduates, which has led to many law school graduates not being hired. "

Umm, no. Again, I do't care how many lawyers you know, you don't know anything about the profession if you think lots of people going to law school = the reason many of my classmates have no jobs. Take a gander at www.abovethelaw.com if you'd like to learn the real reason. This blog entry, lol, too funny!!! I could say more, but I'll stop. Take care and good luck, truly mean that. (in a good way)

 

Blogger Jordan said ... (4:06 PM) : 

Well self-professed Law School Grad I am glad my post invoked so much ire from you. I really appreciate you taking the time to write.

I wish you had read the article that I linked to as it answered a lot of the points you bring up.

As for the wealth of law school students, there are a lot of good data sets about this, but I happen to know specifically about Law School students parent's income based on Economic Labor paper I worked on.

While the data is dated, the gist is true, that Law School students come from an income way above the national average.

This of course reflects a lack of understanding how privilege works; we assume that we come from much poorer means than the reality of the country we live in.

Again entry into law schools is pretty easy, as born out by the article and countless studies in and around the field. Law schools are growing in size and new law schools are opening. What I find is that it is much like dating, if you want to go to ANY school it is easy to find, but finding the right respectable one in your desired location is much harder.

As for the relevance to Black Jewishness I could make a lot of ties to privilege to the locking out of fellow Black Americans from this system, from the lack of quality representation for people of color. I could equally make the case to the over representation (based on higher levels of representation by Jews than our make up of US population) of Jewish Americans in the field and what that says.

But honestly as I pointed out in the article, it is of interest to me personally as a son, grandson, great grandson, great great grandson, great great great grandson of lawyers.

Further the article articulates pretty clearly the glut of lawyers in the field.

I appreciate your passion even though it matches no actual facts and relies entirely on false anecdotal statements.

I wish you good luck as a lawyer, hopefully you can be as upwardly mobile and blind to society as you have always wanted to be.

 

post a comment